Super Simple Stuffed French Toast
This post may contain affiliate links which we may receive commission.
Whenever we go to St. George we HAVE to hit up this little dive called “Bear Paw.” It’s a family favorite and basically – we’ve never ordered anything bad there. Everything is AMAZING and we’re constantly “WOW-ed” by the deliciousness of their food. These guys are KNOWN for their stuffed French Toast.

WHAT?! Yeah. You heard me right. STUFFED FRENCH TOAST. Unreal. Delicious French Toast stuffed with a vanilla (or chocolate) custard and topped with delicious syrup and berries. It’s my favorite thing to order (Yep – I’m THAT girl that goes to the SAME restaurant and orders the SAME dish over and over and over again. Good thing I can share/split some of Handsome’s food, right?)
I love this picture – I know some of my foodie bloggy friends might scoff (where are the props?! haha jk guys!) but this just looks like a regular old piece of bread. No one would EVER suspect that it is, in fact, a stuffed French toast full of amazing goodness inside.


Super Simple Stuffed French Toast
Ingredients
- 1 loaf Texas Toast bread
- Eggs
- Cinnamon
- 1 3.5 box vanilla pudding
Instructions
Pudding
- Prepare pudding according to box. Set aside.
French Toast
- Whisk eggs and cinnamon.
- Dip Texas Toast bread in the egg mixture.
- Cook French Toast
- Cut along the top edge.
- Fill with pudding.
- Cook a few more minutes.
- Serve


This recipe looks amazing! I love that there’s pudding in the middle. I never would have thought of that!
Totally need to try this for an upcoming Waffle Wednesday dinner. We love a good “brinner” recipe!
That looks so yummy!!! Why do you have to post such yummy things to eat!! haha